2017 Keepers
- Double ZO - David Johnson (14th), Sammy Watkins (15th)
- Team Padgette - Devante Parker (7th), Jay Ajayi (15th)
- Frozen Tundra - Doug Martin (14th), Golden Tate (15th)
- Touchdown There - Zeke Elliot (1st), Jason Witten (15th)
- BroD's Bangers - Stefan Diggs (11th), Devonta Freeman (14th)
- Team Patel - Martellus Bennet (12th), Ty Montgomery (15th)
- If You Lose To Me Shoot UR Self - Julio Jones (2nd), Lamar Miller (15th)
- The Swamp Donkeys - Tevin Coleman (9th), Zach Ertz (15th)
- Lisa's FUPA - Derrick Henry (9th), Michael Thomas (12th)
- Show Me Your TDs - Melvin Gordon (6th), Odell Beckham Jr. (15th)
2016 Keepers
- Double ZO - Travis Benjamin (14th), David Johnson (15th)
- Team Padgette - Brandon Marshall (4th), Jay Ajayi (15th)
- Tommy Palarino - Mark Ingram (3rd), Antonio Brown (5th)
- Touchdown There - Rob Gronkowski (7th), De'Angelo Williams (15th)
- BroD's Bangers - Devonta Freeman (14th), Allen Hurns (15th)
- Team Patel - Allen Robinson (6th), LeVeon Bell (15th)
- If You Lose To Me Shoot UR Self - Julio Jones (2nd), Lamar Miller (15th)
- The Swamp Donkeys - Jamaal Charles (1st), Alshon Jeffrey (14th)
- Lisa's FUPA - Jarvis Landry (3rd), Doug Martin (7th)
- Show Me Your TDs - Todd Gurley (4th), Odell Beckham Jr. (15th)
2015 Keepers
- Team Double ZO - CJ Anderson (14th), Mike Evans (15th)
- Team Padgette - Adrian Peterson (1st), Mike Wallace (7th)
- The Merry Pranksters - Antonio Brown (5th), Darren McFadden (15th)
- Touchdown There - Dez Bryant (2nd), Rob Gronkowski (7th)
- Team BroD - Demaryius Thomas (3rd), Eddie Lacy (5th)
- Team Patel - Le'Veon Bell (15th), TY Hilton (4th)
- If You Lose To Me Shoot UR Self - Julio Jones (2nd), Lamar Miller (15th)
- The Swamp Donkeys - Jamaal Charles (1st), Alshon Jeffrey (14th)
- Show Me Your TDs - Matt Forte (2nd), Odell Beckham Jr. (15th)
- Lisa's FUPA - Jeremy Hill (14th), Martavis Bryant (15th)
2014 Keepers
- Team Double ZO - Danny Woodhead (8th), Emmanuel Sanders (15th)
- Team Padgette - Adrian Peterson (1st), DeSean Jackson (6th)
- The Merry Pranksters - Antonio Brown (5th)
- Bobo - Dez Bryant (2nd), Rob Gronkowski (7th)
- Team BroD - Demaryius Thomas (3rd), Eddie Lacy (5th)
- Team Patel - Le'Veon Bell (15th)
- If You Lose To Me Shoot UR Self - Calvin Johnson (1st), Jimmy Graham (3rd)
- The Swamp Donkeys - Jamaal Charles (1st), Alshon Jeffrey (14th)
- Show Me Your TDs - Matt Forte (2nd), Keenan Allen (15th)
- Lisa's FUPA - LeSean McCoy (1st), Julius Thomas (15th)
